I don’t like “random acts of kindness”.
Don, are you insane? Random acts of kindness
are terrific. They make me feel so good! What possible problem do you have with
this?
Now the kindness part is excellent. It’s the randomness
that I object to. Selecting someone at random to be kind to doesn’t make much
sense to me.
The random acts of kindness you hear the about the most is
someone paying for someone’s meal or coffee in the drive-thru line. But the receivers
are chosen at random, with no consideration at all of need.
Yes, it may be fun to do, and it makes the giver and receiver
feel good for a while, but it lacks purpose. And it’s more charity, than kindness.
So, if you labeled these “random acts of charity”, it really loses its zing,
doesn’t it? Few people would write a check and send it to a random, unnamed
organization. And we shouldn’t be kind to people, just because it’s fun.
I much more prefer “purposeful acts of kindness”. This
concept can be summarized in six words:
See the need – Meet the need
See the need – Meet the need
See the need – Meet the need
Even though the concept is simple, actually doing it the
hard part. It’s not difficult to meet most of the needs you encounter. In those
random acts of kindness, you are meeting a need that probably doesn’t even
exist. In purposeful acts of kindness, the challenge is being able to see the
real needs. This can be very tough to accomplish.
To see the needs, you must change your mindset. You must
train your eyes to look for the needs. Those needs are all around us every day,
but we don’t see them because we don’t look for them. Many of the needs are
financial, but some aren’t.
The best example of this is THE MAN, whose time on earth
could be broadly characterized as traveling around, seeing people’s needs, then
meeting people’s needs. He could even see the needs that people didn’t realize they had. Of course, he had supernatural
perception to see the needs and unlimited ability to meet them.
But still, we must ….
See the need – Meet the need
See the need – Meet the need
See the need – Meet the need
Seeing the needs does not come naturally to us. It is a
learned behavior. It requires us to approach life with our eyes wide open. It’s
one of those frustrating things in life where I clearly know what I need to do,
but often fail to do so. Personally, I do much better seeing the needs when I
have time to process the situation. I don’t respond well, quickly, in the
moment.
Here are two personal examples:
Several years ago, I was having breakfast at a Denny’s on a
Sunday morning in Columbus, Ohio, after attending a wedding the previous night.
It happened to be Father’s Day, and as I am eating, I notice a man arriving
with his two young sons. I’m guessing the oldest being around five years of
age.
I imagine they are nearby residents in the inner-city. The
mother isn’t present. Now, this could be just a “boys” only event”, but sending
a guy out with two young sons can be an adventure. Maybe he’s a single father. Perhaps
this is a weekend visitation thing. Regardless, in a culture when men routinely
abandon their young children and shirk their responsibilities, this guy had
made a choice to take his two young sons out for breakfast on Father’s Day.
See the need – That guy should be rewarded for his effort.
We walked by their booth on the way out. I stopped, smiled,
looked at everyone, placed a $20 bill on the table. Said, “Happy Father’s Day!
Breakfast is on me”, and left. Meet the
need.
Oh yes, that looks so impressive Don, but let’s move on to
example two:
Earlier this year (before social distancing), I was
standing in line at the service counter at a grocery store, waiting to mail a
package. The elderly lady in front of me at the counter was having some type of
dispute with the clerk over a charge.
I could only make out bits of the discussion, but it was
the type of dispute we all have been involved in. We think we have been unfairly
charged and owed money back, but the store policy dictates we are not getting a
refund. The amount in question was under $12. The older woman, of course, kept
stating her case and becoming more agitated. The young clerk continued to
repeat company policy, growing exasperated. I, was becoming impatient, having
to wait until this debate ended, knowing my exchange would only take a minute
to complete. Finally, the woman left upset because she didn’t get any money
back.
I was still thinking about this encounter as I walked back
to my car, when I realized I had failed to see the need, and subsequently
failed to meet the need.
As soon as I ascertained the amount of money in dispute was
minor, I could have intervened, gave the older woman $12, or even $20, if I
didn’t have the exact amount, and wished her a nice day.
Instead of her being upset for the next few days and telling
all her friends how horribly she was treated by that young, uncaring clerk, she
would have been joyous she got her $12 back. And the clerk would also be happy
that she did not upset an elderly customer by enforcing a store policy, which
may not even have been fair in this instance.
In this case, I failed to see the need, even as it played
out right in front of my face. And because I failed to see the need, I didn’t
meet the need.
See the need – Meet the need
See the need – Meet the need
See the need – Meet the need
In part two, I will offer you a trick to help – see the
need – this Christmas season.
This is a nice thought.
ReplyDeleteI'm going to disagree with you on a minor point though. The dispute at the cash register might not have been helped by your giving the customer money, bc she may have either been embarrassed by a complete stranger giving her money or it would have been a principle thing: not the money as much as the fact that she was overcharged. Still it was a nice thought.
When I waitressed years ago and someone wanted to treat someone else by paying their bill, they would just pay the bill when they paid their own and say something like, "Please let them know their meal is on me." I always thought that was nice. :)
I do like random acts of kindness, though I agree with your overall point about meeting specific needs. Why can't it be both?
Your point about specific needs reminds me also a little bit about Ahisma, also known as dynamic harmlessness. A slightly different concept, but basically you look at every decision you make and try to make the one that causes the least amount of harm and the most good. Sounds simple, right? It's not. You apply this decision making process to everything, from the food you eat, the products you consume, the way you drive, etc.
Anyway, I really enjoyed your post. Looking forward to the next one!
Yes, I assumed the woman at the cash register needed the money. If it was principle, she was going to lose, and in all likelihood she wasn't cheated but didn't understand the situation. So, I still should have acted and tried to be kind. Thanks for the support.
ReplyDelete